Federal Contractor Misconduct Database (FCMD)

The federal government routinely awards contracts to companies with histories of misconduct, including contract fraud and other violations. POGO believes that providing this website will help to improve contracting decisions and increase public knowledge of how the government spends billions of taxpayer dollars each year. Read more…

Bautista v. Valero Energy Corporation (Unfair Business Practices)

Plaintiffs in a California class-action lawsuit accused Valero and its CST Brands subsidiary of unfair business practices for charging customers who pay for gasoline with debit cards the higher credit price rather than the lower advertised cash price. The plaintiffs claimed the practice of advertising a lower cash price but charging debit card users the higher credit price was misleading because a reasonable consumer believes that a debit card is the equivalent of cash. In September 2020 Valero settled the lawsuit, agreeing to pay up to $1.65 million for attorney fees and expenses and to change its signage at gas stations to include debit card prices along with cash and credit prices.

Misconduct Type
Consumer Affairs
Enforcement Agency
Contracting Party
Court Type
Date of Complaint
Contractors Involved Penalty
Valero Energy Corp. $1,650,000
Further Information Released
Settlement Agreement 9/30/2020
Complaint 12/4/2015

Federal Contractor Misconduct Database